‘My Octopus Teacher’ Was Mesmerizing But There’s 1 Thing That Deeply Troubled Me

Recently, Jacinta Shackleton, a marine biologist stationed at Australias Great Barrier Reef, recorded a blanket octopus (the primary one was spotted 21 years ago) whereas snorkeling. I used to be excited to see photographs of the extremely elusive creature, however I couldnt cease occupied with what would have occurred if somebody who watched My Octopus Teacher, final years well-deserved Oscar-winning documentary, had found it. Would they’ve approached and tried to the touch it?

When I watched My Octopus Teacher, about South African filmmaker and conservationist Craig Fosters yearlong underwater interactions with an octopus, I used to be mesmerized by the improbable footage. As a licensed dive grasp and science trainer, nonetheless, I’m involved by the message viewers may take away from the movie: that anybody can strap on weights, descend deep, and begin touching creatures underwater.

I’ve logged a whole bunch of underwater hours and I understand how uncommon it’s to see an octopus or another nocturnal sea creature throughout the day with adequate gentle to movie, not to mention see one depart its crevasse and transfer about freely. Such an expertise is definitely worthy of capturing on digicam. But as a trainer and human caring about our planet, I felt fearful.

I fell in love with scuba diving once I was in my 20s and I would like as many individuals as doable to expertise the joys of respiration underwater and witnessing creatures that appear like they might solely exist in science fiction. However, I additionally need individuals to make good decisions.

Foster claims that he was alone whereas filming, nevertheless it seems to me that he had assist. If he was alone, that worries me, as scuba diving is exponentially riskier when completed solo.

While sporting weights and diving with out coaching or a accomplice is harmful, touching the creatures you encounter is even worse. Dive masters are continuously telling individuals: Take solely photographs, depart solely bubbles. My concern is that most individuals stroll away from watching this masterful movie with a renewed want for closeness with nature, however and not using a sense of what’s applicable for reference to wild animals.

The creator diving at Miami, Florida’s Anglers Reef in 2019.

Courtesy of Lisa Ellen Niver

In 1963, the Bronx Zoo had an exhibit referred to as the Most Dangerous Animal within the World, and it featured only a mirror. The implication was that human beings will be (and infrequently are) harmful to the world round them, to one another, and to themselves. We can definitely see this play out underwater.

During certainly one of my many dives in Cozumel, a diver was antagonizing a barracuda. We by no means dove with him once more. His conduct was unsafe for him, for the fish and for all of us round him. If you contact a rockfish, stonefish or lionfish, chances are you’ll are available in contact with their venomous quills or spines, and you may be poisoned. If you unintentionally scrape your leg or arm on coral, chances are you’ll get coral caught within the wound, and a few kinds of coral are poisonous. Whats extra, coral is fragile, and touching or standing on it will possibly kill it (sadly (*1*)). I’ve seen individuals stick their digicam and fingers right into a coral head or small cave to get a greater picture of an eel. If an eel bites you, it can’t launch its second set of jaws, referred to as the pharyngeal jaws. Someone should kill the eel to take away it from you.

On the road or the seashore, if someones canine runs as much as you, you ask the proprietor if their pet is pleasant. You ask for permission to method or contact. When I used to be strolling within the Canadian wilderness with tour operator Churchill Wild to see wolves and polar bears, there was a 9-year-old in our group. At one level, he crouched down one thing we had been given particular directions to not do and the wolf closest to us instantly turned towards him. All of the adults shortly moved in entrance of the kid and he stood up. Thankfully, nothing occurred to him. It was a daunting and highly effective reminder that after we are out of our regular habitat, we people might not perceive and due to this fact abide by all the principles, even when we expect we all know them.

Sometimes people and wildlife merge and evolve collectively in surprising methods. Years in the past, many individuals who fish in Grand Cayman started to wash their catch in a single spot and the stingrays across the island got here for the free lunch. Now, the world is named Stingray City, a vacationer vacation spot the place individuals can see and swim with many stingrays in a single place.

An identical factor occurred in Oslob, Cebu, within the Philippines, the place the whale sharks had been following the fishing boats. People on the boats threw krill within the route of the sharks and somebody noticed it on YouTube. Then the vacationers got here. When I used to be there, a marine biologist gave us directions to remain 9 ft from the varsity bus-sized creatures. However, nobody gave this memo to the whale sharks. When people and wildlife come collectively regardless of how stunning or thrilling it could appear we nonetheless must do not forget that these creatures are wild and that we have to respect that, so we dont damage them or their habitat (and so we dont get damage, both).

The author diving with sharks in Playa Del Carmen, Mexico in 2016.
The creator diving with sharks in Playa Del Carmen, Mexico in 2016.

Courtesy of ProfessionalDive International

Our pure world wants our assist. While I imagine My Octopus Teacher has introduced the surprise of the oceans and their creatures to thousands and thousands of individuals, I’m nonetheless troubled by the promotion of the concept its secure to enter the personal world of one other creature (particularly by your self) and contact it with out consent. Im not claiming that Foster is or ever would counsel that anybody do what he did, however impressionable viewers might not be capable of separate his actions from their very own, and that could possibly be bother for everybody concerned.

Foster makes clear that his reference to the octopus heals him, and after months of staying at house as a result of COVID, most of us are looking out to resume {our relationships} with ourselves, one another, and the pure world. But we have to do that with care and warning. We must put the well-being of those creatures earlier than our personal needs. And we have to do not forget that what occurs in a film even a documentary isnt permission to do it ourselves.

I hope that everybody who cherished this movie will discover a method to look after our planets ocean environments by supporting the institution of extra marine protected areas, decreasing plastic, selecting up trash, and being sort to the unbelievable marine animals and environments we’d encounter. Sometimes the easiest way to be sort to them is to go away them alone to be happy with the present of a glimpse of their magnificence and nothing extra.

As Shackleton just lately reminded us, there are a lot of creatures nonetheless being found and practically 80% of our underwater world is but unmapped. I hope this latest sighting of the blanket octopus and My Octopus Teacher evokes many others to discover. There are terrific adventures to be discovered throughout our planet, however we have to take part in ways in which maintain each us and the creatures we encounter secure from hurt.

Lisa Ellen Niver is an award-winning journey knowledgeable who has explored 101 nations and 6 continents. Her writing has appeared in Wired, Teen Vogue, Smithsonian Magazine, Ms. Magazine, the Jewish Journal, and plenty of different on-line and print publications. She is writing a memoir about reinvention after 50. Find her speaking journey on Instagram and Twitter at @lisaniver, and on her YouTube channel, which has over 1.5 million views. Read extra of her work at lisaniver.com/one-page/.

Do you’ve got a compelling private story youd prefer to see revealed on HuffPost? Find out what had been on the lookout for right here and ship us a pitch!


fbq(‘init’, ‘1621685564716533’);
fbq(‘track’, “PageView”);

var _fbPartnerID = null;
if (_fbPartnerID !== null) {
fbq(‘init’, _fbPartnerID + ”);
fbq(‘track’, “PageView”);

(function () {
‘use strict’;
document.addEventListener(‘DOMContentLoaded’, function () {
document.body.addEventListener(‘click’, function(event) {
fbq(‘track’, “Click”);


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button