Executive Overview: The Fine Line Between Boldness and Chaos
In the modern marketing landscape, the mandate for global brands is clear: adapt or vanish. However, as the digital ecosystem becomes increasingly fragmented and the influence of artificial intelligence accelerates, the definition of "boldness" has become dangerously conflated with "chaos."
During a keynote session at Brandweek 2026, Rankin Carroll, Chief Brand Officer of Mars Snacking, articulated a compelling philosophy for the modern CMO. For Carroll, who oversees iconic powerhouses like M&M’s, Snickers, and Skittles, creative risk-taking should indeed induce a level of professional nervousness. However, he posits that if a brand’s boldest move leaves stakeholders—or consumers—asking "Why are they doing this?", then the strategy has fundamentally failed.
This article explores the nuanced framework Carroll uses to maintain brand equity while pushing the boundaries of technology and culture. By analyzing the 2023 Snickers AI experiment and examining the broader responsibilities of leadership in an era of rapid technological disruption, we uncover how one of the world’s largest snack companies manages the tension between protecting heritage and inviting the future.
Detailed Chronology: The Evolution of Risk at Mars
To understand where Mars is heading, one must look at the "laboratory" environment of the last three years. The company’s trajectory has not been one of unbridled technological adoption, but rather one of guarded, strategic experimentation.
The 2023 Snickers AI Experiment: A Case Study in Calculated Risk
In 2023, the artificial intelligence landscape was far more volatile and less understood than it is today. When Mars launched an agentic creative experience for Snickers, it was, by Carroll’s own admission, "potentially crazy."
The project was not merely a marketing gimmick; it was a stress test for the company’s internal infrastructure. The initiative required the alignment of roughly ten distinct technology partners, alongside the heavy lifting of legal and security leadership. To mitigate the existential risk of brand dilution or reputation-damaging AI outputs, the team implemented a list of 8,000 "blocked words."
The success of the project did not lie in the sophistication of the AI alone, but in the collaborative commitment of the organization. Carroll notes that ambitious experimentation only becomes possible when the entire corporate structure—from the boardroom to the dev team—commits to solving the risk together rather than passing the buck.
From Pilots to Policy
Following the 2023 experiment, Mars moved away from the "thousand pilots" model that currently plagues many multinational organizations. Carroll argues that leaving AI adoption to disconnected enthusiasts across an organization is a recipe for internal friction and fragmented brand identity. Instead, he has championed a top-down approach where CMOs partner directly with technology leadership to determine what the company should build, buy, rent, or borrow. This shift marks a transition from reactive, decentralized testing to proactive, integrated innovation.
Supporting Context & Metrics: The Philosophy of Stewardship
Rankin Carroll’s career, spanning over two decades at Mars, has taken him from Toronto to the UK, overseeing diverse portfolios including the company’s expansive ice cream business. His tenure has solidified his definition of the Chief Brand Officer’s role: stewardship.
Protecting the Core While Creating Tension
Stewardship, in Carroll’s view, is a three-fold mandate:
- Protect: Defend the attributes that make a brand iconic.
- Enhance: Ensure the brand is stronger when it leaves your hands than when it arrived.
- Tension: Inject just enough cultural friction to keep the brand from stagnating.
This framework is particularly vital for brands like Skittles. When asked how Skittles maintained its relationship with the LGBTQ+ community during a period of intense sociopolitical volatility, Carroll emphasized the necessity of "earned credibility."
"My filter for every big swing is simple: Why us? Why this brand?" Carroll explained. If the brand has not spent years building a genuine, authentic relationship with a community, a sudden, performative campaign will be correctly identified as opportunistic. The risk is only worth taking if there is a strategically convincing answer that links the brand’s history to its current action.
Official Statements: Addressing the Generational Crisis
Perhaps the most significant takeaway from the Brandweek 2026 discussion was Carroll’s candid admission regarding the future of the marketing workforce. As AI begins to perform the tasks traditionally assigned to junior staff—copywriting, basic asset generation, and data synthesis—the industry faces a looming talent crisis.
The "Training Gap"
"Are we preparing the next generation for what marketing becomes next?" Carroll asked the audience, acknowledging that he does not yet have a satisfying answer.
He anticipates that the daily practice of marketing will look unrecognizable within the next three years. Because the industry is moving faster than current educational and internship pipelines, Carroll identifies talent development as a primary leadership responsibility. It is no longer an HR afterthought; it is a strategic imperative. If leaders fail to mentor junior marketers on how to leverage AI as a tool rather than a replacement, they risk losing the "human touch" that keeps iconic brands rooted in emotional resonance.
The "Just Because" Fallacy
Carroll offered a blunt warning to the marketing community regarding the AI frenzy: "Just because you can use AI somewhere does not mean you should." This sentiment serves as a counter-narrative to the current trend of implementing technology for the sake of efficiency alone. For Mars, the brand’s voice, integrity, and safety remain the primary constraints. Technology is the engine, but the brand strategy must remain the steering wheel.
Future Outlook: The Next Three Years
As we look toward the remainder of the decade, the strategy for Mars Snacking is clear: move from the era of "innovation as a spectacle" to "innovation as a utility."
Leadership and the "Unified Agenda"
The future of brand management, according to Carroll, will require a new type of leader—one who is as comfortable in a meeting with software engineers as they are in a creative brief review. The separation between the "creative" and the "technical" is becoming an archaic distinction. The next phase of growth for brands like M&M’s and Snickers will depend on the ability to integrate generative processes into a consistent brand narrative that respects the consumer’s intelligence.
The Sustainability of Boldness
Ultimately, the "best" creative risks will continue to be those that make us nervous. But as the tools at our disposal become more powerful, the responsibility of the C-suite becomes more profound. By grounding every experiment in strategic necessity and ensuring that the organization is aligned on risk management, Mars is setting a benchmark for how heritage brands can remain culturally relevant in a digital-first, AI-augmented world.
The takeaway for CMOs globally is a call to action: stop chasing the shiny object of the week. Instead, focus on building an organizational culture that rewards thoughtful, collaborative, and, above all, purposeful risk. When the "Why" is clear, the "How" becomes a matter of execution rather than a gamble with the brand’s soul.
This article is part of a special vidcast series recorded live at Brandweek 2026 and presented in partnership with Tatari. For more insights on the future of brand leadership, visit the Brandweek archives.